Home » Brown in America, Crime, Desi Please, Maccaca Crimewatch, Racism

Hindi speakers attacked in Bay Area

From Santosh On 24 February 2009 View Comments

Four Hindi speaking residents in the Bay area were attacked in what appears to be a racially motivated crime. [NBC]

The victims appear to be random selected ….

Police said four victims had left a bar and were walking to their car in a parking lot in the 200 block of Castro Street when they were approached by two female suspects.

The two female suspects allegedly approached a female victim and began punching and slapping her.

…. but the attack appears to be planned and coordinated.

When the victim’s husband intervened, a group of four to six male suspects appeared, dragging the husband away from his wife, police said. The suspects then began to punch and kick the husband.

Two other male victims attempted to intervene but were also punched, police said.

The suspects then fled in two different vehicles, according to police.

The scary part is the alleged motive behind the attack.

The suspects harassed the victims, who were speaking Hindi, and made racially charged comments about their ethnicity and the language they were using, police said.

Fortunately, one of the victims got a license plate number which has resulted in some arrests.

Even though the article seems to stress on Hindi, the premise that the victims were selected based of their South Asian appearance cannot be discounted. Hopefully, this is just a random occurrence and not an alarming trend in attacks on South Asians.

Looks like you've just discovered us. Add our RSS feed to keep up with the new posts.

  • Rajesh,
    We seem to be getting more of these hit-n-run comments. Not sure where these idiots are coming from.
    Usually we let people express their opinions as long as they don't cross the line. The comment above yours did.
  • Rajesh
    Boy O Boy, Santosh the comments in Uberdesi are slowly giving rediff a run for their money. Is that good or bad? :-)
  • Siggy
    Hi my name is Siggy and I'm a racist a'hole.
  • Praveen
    Sorry if it sounded so but I'm not in any way justifying the violence. Just trying to find reasons why it happened.

    There is definitely an undercurrent of frustration of non Hindi speaking Desis against the Hindi ones. Have heard from fellow Singapore/Malaysian Desis about they get treated by these people.

    By Desi, here I mean anyone of Indian race and not nationality.

    In this case, the culprits are Hispanics and these people usually tend to interact most with Desi business owners who are again mostly Hindi/Punjabi. The Hispanics' generally lower standard of earning could lead to frustration against these Desis. FYI, East Palo Alto and the part of Mountain View where this happened is dominated by Hispanics.
  • Runa
    And young geenration is occupied using the power of blogging, pod casting to disect chandni chowk to china and billu barber.


    Not just the young - the middle aged too!
    To be fair to Sunny he was JOKING
  • rohit
    and bobby jindal!
  • rohit
    http://www.mv-voice.com/news/show_story.php?id=...

    local americans btw seem to have a lot better rational viewpoints than the ones mentioned here.

    Hate crimes can spiral into a community vs community agendas esp in these times of economic meltdown when there would be plenty of people having nothing to do but to express their anger at their current situation.

    Sunny: I see your comments as equally irresponsible. I am aghast at seeing indians being so indifferent to their own community and show such disdain for india and everything indian.

    What ram sena did was equally wrong - and not becasue they carry different opinions (which I see as ok) but that they used violence to strike fear in the hearts of people who carry a different view point.

    Non violence preached by gandhi ji carried a special meaning esp for most of indifferent, divided, violent indians of that time (and this time! ) - It meant that if india gained independence without this one virtue, it would fall in chaos because people will simply start hating and hitting each other due to various divisions and varied viewpoints. He made it possible for India to gain independence, not before its time has come, but atleast to survive this long by ensuring non violence always stayed as a national, hindu and personal virtue. We get respect due to this at international level - see some comments from above link.

    Too bad , that man is simply forgotten as coward in most intellectual circles. And young geenration is occupied using the power of blogging, pod casting to disect chandni chowk to china and billu barber.
  • rohit
    Praveen, I sincerely hope that you are not indian. And perhaps you are not - sinhalese or urdu speaking maybe, in which case I would understand your lack of empathy for Hindi speaking people of India. Humanity and compassion are not virtues shared by many now a days and one should not unfairly expect that either. However, if you are indian then i must add "shame on you" for justifying the beatings in the name of speaking "hindi" - an indian language represented by majority of your brothers esp at the front lines who would when time calls for it, lay down their lives saying their last words in HINDI.
  • rohit
    Praveen, you seem to put on display your sick mind by justifying the beatings - its no differrent than the people who beat up those inocent couple.

    By that account, anyone speaking german or arabic shoudl be beaten up in india - right?
  • Praveen,
    JMHO but it's unfair to extrapolate the actions of a few to all people from that region.
    Besides beating up anyone isn't the answer, whatever be the issue. Heck, I speak Hindi, Tamil and (a little bit of) Marathi and wouldn't want to get beaten up by anyone just because I was speaking a particular language someone else did not like or approve of.
  • Praveen
    Maybe the Hindi speaking part really matters. Have lived in the Bay Area for a while and I get nauseated by these Hindi jingoists. They dont care about the surroundings , insist everyone speak Hindi, go about saying that everyone in the world not only in India should speak in Hindi and all that bull.

    Had experienced harassment for not being able to speak in Hindi and I almost ended up filing a discrimination suit against a colleague for that.

    There are a large number of non-Hindi people including Sri Lankans who are sick and tired of the behaviour of the Hindi people.
  • Sunny
    Note that the victims were coming out from a bar - maybe the attackers were goons hired by Shree Ram Sena!!
blog comments powered by Disqus