Home » Brown in America, Entertainment, Music

Review: XM Channel 159 ATN Asian Radio

From Santosh On 28 March 2008 View Comments

My search for desi music on radio led me to invest in XM satellite radio. Previously, I never drove that much and for the short drives between home and work, I had enough music on CDs to get by. But now that I moved and am driving more, it was time to get more venues of entertainment or so I thought. To me there was no difference between XM and Sirius in terms of the kind of programming I prefer but XM has a desi music station, so I decided to go with XM.

XM Channel 159My first impressions on the desi music stations on XM, channel 159 ATN Asian Radio, is that its still years away from being a semi-decent satellite radio station. Right now channel 159 has about 2 major shows they play over and over again, or at least it seems that way – Bollywood Bonanza and Desi Mix. My biggest peeve is their morning programming. As I’m on my way to work I’ve to skip this channel entirely because they play Bhajans and other devotional music. I can’t speak for all desis but devotional music on my way to work is not a selling point to me. Perhaps XM Channel 159 caters to an older crowd, perhaps they did not do their market research and went with the lowest common denominator. Either way, 7:30am-9am is prime time for radio because most people are probably on their way to work during this time period. A morning news or current affairs show would be a greater fit for this segment.

The best feature I like about satellite radio is when a song is playing the receiver unit displays the name of the song and the artist. No such luck with channel 159. All you see is the name of the show – “Bollywood Bonanza” or “Desi Mix”, which, pardon my French, blows, because it won’t let me set a song as a preselected favorite.

Bollywood Bonanza is primarily recent Bollywood movies numbers and Desi Mix is Indi-Pop and remix numbers, not that there is often a major difference between the two. Bollywood Bonanza also features interviews with Bollywood celebrities, often featuring mind numbing statements like “You look fit now, earlier you had put on some weight” “Ya ya, I’ve been working out”. Desi Mix features an interactive call-in radio show which is perhaps the most entertaining part of channel 159. The most amusing callers are the ones who harp endlessly on “Indian culture and traditions” irrespective of the topic being discussed. Until listening to these delusional folks, I was under the impression that harping on “Indian culture” was the prerogative of middle aged uncles from a Hindu background. After listening to this segment, all such misconceptions on age, sex and religion have been cleared. But I digress.

Other shows include Ghazals, Oldies and Regional Languages. I’ve not had the opportunity to peruse the first two largely because of their weird scheduling and not being big on regional language music, I pretty much skip over that show.

To sum it up, the new desi channel on satellite radio is ….. a fledgling radio station. Their programming needs some serious upgrading to be at the level of a satellite radio station and to appeal to a wider variety of audiences. Talk shows, news, current affairs, finance, sports (cricket, in particular, preferably live) are some of the things that would fit in well should they choose to upgrade. Being the first South Asian channel on satellite radio, they have the potential to draw a sizable audience, maybe they already are. But that audience certainly deserves better, translation we don’t need a clone of All India Radio. Right now, the programming is strictly quantity over quality. We deserve better.

Any of our readers listen to this station on XM? Thoughts? Opinions? Any information you want to add?

Looks like you are one of our regular visitors. Here is our RSS feed, just another way to keep up with the new posts.

  • RB
    The quality of the audio is very poor. I've been an XM subscriber for 2 years and it appears they have no interest in addressing it. My other major issue is the deejays who host Bollywood Bananza and Desi Mix. They seem to have no radio experience and at times I have to change the station because their inane blathering gets to be too much. The Desi Mix deejay seems to think that speaking in a sing-song cadence, emphasizing random syllables, makes her sound professional. Ninety percent of what comes out of her mouth is per verbal diarrhea. I have no interest in listening to her read someone's 2-page song request letter, and then follow up with 10 minutes explaining in 120 different ways that she is, indeed, about to play the request. The deejay for Bollywood Bananza should stick to playing music and not reading outdated Bollywood gossip off of the internet while on air. They need to either hire trained deejays who know how to speak succinctly and get to the music, or just play the music without the useless deejays.
  • Amar Gandhi
    I wish I had read the review before I subscribed to XM for Desi music.
    While the guzals and oldies are ofetn quiet good, shows like bollywood bonanza and desi mix are truly irritating.

    What is depressing is tha the DJs cant pronounce the names of artist to save ther lives. I realize they must be brought up in the western world but come'on. Atleast learn to pronounce the names of people you are talking about.

    Sound quality to put it loosely is horrid.

    I am cancelling my sub when it runs out. Not worth spending on crappy chan. like ATN
  • Nikhil,
    All this while I thought it was the crappy music they were playing. I guess compressing it down to 14 kbps doesn't help :-)
  • Nikhil
    I am surprised no one has commented about the quality of audio. Its sounds like its compressed down to 14kbps - worse than most online radio stations. I cant get myself to listen long enough to be able to comment on programming content.
  • Runa
    I can’t speak for all desis but devotional music on my way to work is not a selling point to me.

    My theory:
    Its a throwback to the des where devotional music is popular while driving so that there is some control over road rage that would otherwise go out of proportion while fighting to get to office on time. Look at traffic in Delhi/Ahmedabad/Pune - its a wonder that more people do not get killed in road rage incidents since everyone drives like a maniac :-) Those bhajans help :-)
  • I used to have the same problem when I lived back east, now in the 'mornings' they play crappier hindi music. ;)

    I guess they were targeting the west coast for listeners.
  • CB
    That's pretty cool. Once your parents find out about this channel its over.
blog comments powered by Disqus