Über Desi

Keeping it real, desi ishtyle

Blood transfusions gone wild: A case of blood sucking desi parents

Tags: , , , ,

When it comes to grades in school and career choices, all desi kids experience parental pressure at different stages in life. Some quotes (translated in English) overheard in real life:
“Mohan beta, how could Raju score 92% marks, and you only get 87%? Your career and life are ruined ……..”
“There is no scope in music/sports. Why don’t you go into engineering/medicine ………”

Blood TransfusionBlood transfusions – a dumb way to get smarter

I would venture to say that probably that most remarks of this nature are well intentioned, hurtful as they might be. However, these parents from Rohtak, who happen to be doctors took things too far (tip: Runa via Tipster).

Faced with the tragedy that perhaps their older son was not smart enough to get into MBBS school, the doctor couple from Rohtak were at their wits end. Then a guru appeared in the mother’s dreams and suggested a miraculous technique to make the kid smartertransfuse him with blood from his smarter younger brother.

Investigations revealed that while Piyush, a class VI student, excelled in studies, 18-year-old Abhishek, who was preparing for medical entrance examinations, was an average student. The couple was desperate to get him enrolled in an MBBS course.
The superstitious mother reportedly saw the ‘guru’ in her dream, who advised her to transfuse the blood of Piyush to Abhishek for his sure admission to a medical college. He also directed her to spill oil and burn something to create smoke in the house during the transfusion.

The cliche goes “what doesn’t kill you makes you stronger”. But what if it kills you? No one to this day, has answered the all important question to the cliche.

The operation, however, went haywire and the younger sibling died of excessive bleeding.

We often blame illiteracy in India for the existence of asinine superstitions even in the 21st century. Turns out even educated people are not immune to superstitions.

What’s shocking is that the mother, Dr Promila Malik, is a professor in Pandit Bhagat Dayal Sharma Post Graduate Institute of Medical Sciences (PGIMS) here and the father, Dr Ashok Malik, is employed in a hospital at Amritsar. Apparently, the ‘guru’ used to appear in the mother’s dreams.

Rohtak police made this startling revelation on Wednesday, after investigating into the incident in which Piyush (12) was killed and his brother Abhishek and their mother Promila were found injured in their house in the PGIMS campus on October 1. They arrested the parents after registering cases under sections 304 and 120 B of IPC. Police had also seized material like mustard and kerosene oil, incense sticks and matchbox, indicating that tantrik rituals had been performed in the house. Superintendent of police Haneef Quraishi said some family member could be involved in the incident. “We have interrogated the father and the family’s 14-year-old domestic help who revealed that Promila had faith in the magical remedies of a tantrik. We have found blood-soaked syringes and needles.”

Nimbu MirchiThis story brings forth so many issues facing urban educated Indians. Excessive parental pressure, abundance of quacks masquerading as doctors and the existence of superstitious practices even among the educated elite of society.

While discussing this story with some friends, they rightly pointed out that not all educated people succumb to such extreme superstitions and engage in tantrik rituals. That may be correct but a lot of educated people of Indian origin, engage in some equally mind-numbing, albeit harmless, rituals. One of them is the nimbu and mirchi (pictured left) to ward off evil spirits. This is widely used in homes and businesses in India and Indian-owned homes and businesses abroad. The other one that comes to mind is the kaala teeka (black mark) on the face of children to ward off evil eyes, again, practiced by Indians in the des and abroad. These are superstitions sponsored by organized religion, victimless, but asinine nevertheless. The problem with superstitions sponsored by organized religion is where do you draw a line? Sure blood and gore are not standard fare in superstitions in Indian society but they (superstitions) represent a weak mind. This weakness, in our minds, as Runa points out, is exploited by unscrupulous elements on the fringes of organized religion – godmen, sadhus, babas, tantriks, quacks, shamans, exorcists, etc. The innocuous nimbu and mirchi does not get anyone killed but it starts a slippery slope. People who indulge in one are not above indulging in an equally, if not more, silly superstition sponsored by organized religion and somewhere, the line gets crossed.

Full disclosure: Like mentioned above, educated individuals are not above indulging in superstitions and I’m not immune to it. I’m immensly superstitious when it comes to watching sports and it does come from a weak mind. My two favorite teams (1,2) are stinking up the joint and I’ve not slept for days on end. But fear not, no tantriks or blood transfusions have been involved as of yet.

Everyone has their own favorite superstition. What is your guilty pleasure? Any other thoughts or opinions on superstitions in our culture or parental pressure facing desi youngsters?

Looks like you are one of our regular visitors. Here is our RSS feed, just another way to keep up with the new posts.

Tags: , , , ,

  • umm….where do I get a lizard here?


    More importantly, How do you figure out which lizard is a male and which is a female? (And that was a rhetorical question. )
  • oops did I mention, they have a whole piece of literature for the lizard falling on a specific area of your body - eg:
    male - lizard falls on thigh - loss of clothing
    female -lizard falls on thigh - expect romance

    umm....where do I get a lizard here?
  • accidentally stepping on a book will make me a nincompoop automatically if I don't pray for forgiveness (to the book or it's goddess)

    kala tikka is one thing, kala billi is another BIG thing

    sneezing (funnily, a bad omen in my place but a good omen at my cousin's place, so not sure what to say, I guess place matters)

    handing salt (or sesame seeds) directly by hand (instead of placing it on the table or a platform), salt is supposed to bring up fights between two people who exchanged it directly by hand,

    I could go on and on (I was my grandma's fav grandchild :) )
    but then there's a whole set of explanations (feeble and strong)

    if u handle salt directly and accidentally drop it on ur plate or the other person's plate, u MUST fight especially if u r two bachelors :)

    then cutting nails after dark, or sweeping home after dark.....reason I believe, long long ago, when there was no electrikitty , u wouldnt do a good job of cleaning ur nails or ur house and redo it again in daylight - so dont do it after dark, unless u have laxman sylvania :)
  • Ahh, now I get it.

    Note to self: I can now sue mom. :)
  • Runa
    Karthik,
    The superstition is :
    The first born is never fed the first dosa /roti made .Its always the second + . Of course a tava is used - its just that the first dosa/roti made in the batch is not fed to the eldest.Don't ask me why !
  • I have used the Kala tikka when my son was a baby.


    This I know of and in fact a lot of other cultures have similar traditions. The Greek people have their evil eye thing.

    I never cut his nails after dark .

    This I have heard of and it also is the same for combing hair and throwing away hair in the evenings (when it is dark outside). It is apparently because people can take it (considered part of your body) and use it for black magic.


    I never fed him the first dosa/roti off the tava.

    I have never heard of it. In fact, I will need more info on what you exactly mean... How can you make dosa/roti without a tava?
  • Runa,
    You're welcome. Thx again for the uber tip.

    I never cut his nails after dark .

    The kaala teeka we all know and the dosa-tava thing I've heard of. The nails after dark thing is new to me.
  • Runa
    Hey Santosh,
    Thrilled that the tip resulted in a story! You bring out a very important point: where to draw the line between harmless superstition and crackpot beliefs? While I have a deep distrust of godmen, tantriks etc I am guilty of my own superstitions - specially when it comes to my child.All these the result of listening to old wives' tales: I have used the Kala tikka when my son was a baby.I never cut his nails after dark .I never fed him the first dosa/roti off the tava.
blog comments powered by Disqus

© 2009 Über Desi. All Rights Reserved.

This blog is powered by Wordpress and Magatheme by Bryan Helmig.